Haley Thogmartin was eliminated from Big Brother Season 28 in a “Medieval Times” twist, going out the door before jury and confirmed by a black-and-white photo appearing on the Memory Wall when the live feeds returned. Her exit came through a genuinely unusual competition format that temporarily handed control of the house to a panel of returning Big Brother legends rather than the season’s own houseguests.
What the Medieval Times Twist Actually Was
The twist brought back four former Big Brother houseguests — Britney Haynes, Tiffany Mitchell, Keanu Soto and Cody Calafiore — to host a series of games for the show’s 10 remaining players, with the stakes built around a single elimination rather than the show’s normal nomination-and-vote structure. Haley lost, and was removed from the game immediately, without the usual eviction-night vote or jury placement other exiting houseguests get later in a season. Once the twist concluded, the season reverted to its regular structure: Drew Campbell won the following Head of Household competition and nominated Lala Verrett, Taylor Brown and Yash Patel for the next eviction.
Who Is Haley Thogmartin
Thogmartin is 29, from Neosho, Missouri, and works as a telemedicine executive, having held a Director of Operations role at Viking Alternative Medicine. Before entering the Big Brother house, she was a Division I softball pitcher at Southeast Missouri State University, posting a 2.04 ERA in 2018 and helping the Redhawks win the Ohio Valley Conference championship in 2019. She described her own game approach around her athletic background and ability to connect with people, entering the season believing that combination gave her a real competitive edge.
Why This Twist Format Matters for the Season
Big Brother has used celebrity-alumni-hosted twists before, but pulling a houseguest out of the game entirely — bypassing jury placement and the normal live vote — is a more disruptive move than a typical special competition. It changes the season’s math immediately: a player who might have otherwise survived on strategy or alliances within the house had no vote to campaign for, no jury speech, and no chance to influence the outcome once the twist’s games began. For a season already generating buzz around unpredictable format changes, Haley’s elimination is being read by fans less as a normal eviction and more as evidence that production is willing to use non-standard mechanics to reshape the game mid-season.
Part of a Season Built Around Constant Format Disruption
Big Brother Season 28 premiered July 7, 2026, with 17 houseguests under a “Time Trip” theme, airing during the franchise’s landmark 1,000th episode milestone — and the season has leaned unusually hard into disrupting its own normal rules from the start, including a Time Capsule twist, Survivor contestants entering the game, and a returning former houseguest joining mid-season. The Medieval Times elimination fits that same pattern: rather than a standard week built around an HOH’s nominations and a Veto competition, the whole structure was replaced by an alumni-run gauntlet with a single, immediate elimination attached to it. For a season explicitly promoted around “turning time into the ultimate twist,” Haley’s exit is the clearest example yet of production prioritizing unpredictability over the show’s usual competitive rhythm.
Frequently Asked Questions
How was Haley Thogmartin eliminated from Big Brother 28?
Through a “Medieval Times” twist hosted by returning Big Brother alumni Britney Haynes, Tiffany Mitchell, Keanu Soto and Cody Calafiore, which resulted in her elimination before the jury phase.
Who is Haley Thogmartin?
A 29-year-old telemedicine executive from Neosho, Missouri, and a former Division I softball pitcher at Southeast Missouri State University.
Who became Head of Household after the twist?
Drew Campbell, who nominated Lala Verrett, Taylor Brown and Yash Patel for eviction.
Did Haley make it to the jury?
No — she was eliminated pre-jury as part of the twist, without the show’s usual eviction vote.
The Bottom Line
Haley Thogmartin’s exit is notable less for who she is individually and more for how she left — a returning-cast-hosted twist that removed a houseguest outside the show’s normal voting structure entirely. For a Division I athlete who came into the house believing her competitive background would carry her deep into the season, the format that ended her run gave her no chance to compete for survival at all.
