Ithaca Bars: The Commons and Beyond
Ithaca’s bar scene runs from brewery taprooms to neighborhood dives, with a strong local-beer and cider presence. This guide covers places in and around the Ithaca Commons, plus a few stops worth a short drive. Hours and tap lists change often, so check before you go.
In and Around the Ithaca Commons
Ithaca Beer Company
Ithaca Beer Company’s taproom, known locally as The Jungle, is at 122 Ithaca Beer Drive, a short drive from downtown rather than on the Commons. The draw is fresh Ithaca Beer pours: Apricot Wheat, Flower Power IPA, seasonals, and small-batch releases. The room is casual and busy on weekends, with live music at times. The food menu goes beyond standard taproom snacks, with pub fare designed to pair with the beer. Check taproom hours before making the trip.
Coltivare
Coltivare at 235 S Cayuga St pairs wood-fired pizza and farm-to-table dishes with a full bar. Cocktails use seasonal ingredients, and the tap list leans on local and regional craft beer. The rooftop seating is the reason to come on a warm evening, with views over downtown and the hills. It is more of a restaurant bar than a late-night spot, so it works best for a drink before dinner or a slower meal with friends.
The Downstairs
The Downstairs sits below Moosewood Restaurant at 215 N Cayuga St. The room is small and dim, with a quieter feel than most Commons bars. Cocktails are the focus, including house-made syrups and infusions, and the beer list covers craft and imported options. Bar snacks are available and designed to go with the drinks. It is a good choice when you want downtown convenience without the noise of a packed pub.
Gorgers Burritos
Gorgers Burritos at 120 The Commons is a burrito counter with a useful beer list. The taps rotate through local and regional craft breweries, pours are generous, and prices stay reasonable for downtown. The room is casual and often busy with students. Order a burrito, get a local beer, and keep the evening simple.
Neighborhood Bars and Casual Stops
The Westy
The Westy at 516 W State St in the West End is a neighborhood bar with a refreshed room and the same unpretentious feel. The tap list includes local beers, prices are low, and the patio is a plus in warm weather. It draws a regular after-work crowd, with trivia and live music showing up on the calendar. It is a good stop if you want a local bar away from the Commons.
Rullo’s Pizza
Rullo’s Pizza at 317 N Meadow St is a neighborhood pizza place with a bar area. The taps rotate through craft breweries popular in the Finger Lakes, and the setup works for a beer and a slice without turning the night into a production. Expect a mix of students and local families. It is casual, quick, and useful when you want pizza with a decent draft list.
John’s Drive-In Bar
John’s Drive-In at 116 W Jay St is known for burgers and ice cream, but there is also a small bar area next to the main building serving beer and simple mixed drinks. It is a throwback stop, especially in warmer months when outdoor seating is open. Go for a burger, a cold beer, and a low-key Ithaca experience rather than a polished cocktail program.
Craft Beer, Cider, and Pubs
Kilpatrick’s Irish Pub
Kilpatrick’s Irish Pub at 116 N Aurora St is a short walk from the Commons and leans into a traditional Irish pub format. Expect stouts, porters, Irish reds, local craft beers, and a solid whiskey list. Live music, including folk and traditional Irish tunes, is part of the draw. It is a comfortable place for a pint and pub food, especially on a cold evening.
South Hill Cider
South Hill Cider at 1050 Ellis Hollow Rd is a cidery rather than a standard bar, but it belongs in any Ithaca drinking guide. The tasting room is rustic and offers flights of ciders made from local apples, from dry traditional styles to experimental batches. Food trucks and live music appear regularly, so check the schedule before you drive out. It is outside downtown, which makes it a destination rather than a quick stop.
Practical Notes
- Getting around: The Commons is walkable, but Ithaca Beer Company and South Hill Cider are not. Use a designated driver, ride-sharing, or TCAT bus routes when you leave downtown.
- Check hours and events: Tap lists, kitchen hours, and live music schedules change. Check a bar’s social media or call before you go, especially on weeknights.
- Ask about local beer: Bartenders can usually tell you which taps come from Finger Lakes breweries. If you like a beer or cider, ask whether a local shop carries it for takeout.
- Seasonal seating: Rooftops and patios fill up in summer. Pubs and dim lounges are better in winter. Seasonal drinks often use local apples and berries.
- Finger Lakes options: Ithaca bars often pour Finger Lakes wine and beer. If you want to explore beyond the city, use the bar list as a starting point for winery and brewery visits.
Ithaca’s bar scene is spread across downtown, West End, and the roads outside town. Start on the Commons, then branch out for a taproom, a neighborhood bar, or a cider flight.
If your company or product is mentioned in this article, you're welcome to share it.


